News & Notes > Preprint withdrawals

Preprint withdrawals

medRxiv  |  2023-08-15

Preprints are a permanent part of the scientific record. They are citable, receive digital object identifiers (DOIs), and are indexed by search engines, Google Scholar, Web of Science, and other third-party services, so they leave persistent digital footprints online. Consequently, bioRxiv, medRxiv, and other responsible preprint servers have policies that articles cannot be removed from the server once posted, except under extraordinary circumstances*.

If authors wish simply to correct information in an article, the best solution is to post a revised version of the preprint containing the appropriate changes. But there are occasionally circumstances in which authors wish to formally withdraw the article because it has flaws to which the community should be alerted to avoid inappropriate use or citation. Examples include cases in which authors discover problems with data and/or find they can no longer stand by their previous conclusions. An article may also be withdrawn by the preprint server if it is notified by an author's institution of an instance of fraud.

When an article is withdrawn, the article HTML is prominently labeled "Withdrawn" (technically the withdrawal constitutes a new version of the article) and the DOI defaults to a statement explaining the reason for the withdrawal. In addition, a "Withdrawn" watermark is added to the PDF files of all prior versions of the text, and starting August 1, 2023, "Withdrawn:" will be added at the beginning of the article title metadata. This ensures that the article's withdrawn status is clear both to bioRxiv/medRxiv readers and to those who encounter references to it in third-party search results and academic indexes.

Like retracted journal articles, withdrawn preprints remain online in bioRxiv/medRxiv (the original manuscript is accessible via the Info/History tab). This preserves the integrity of the scientific record and provides a transparent account of events that ensures innocent parties are not accused of wrongdoing. An author is permitted to update a withdrawn preprint with a new version in which the flaw is remedied. In this case, the DOI defaults to the new version but the withdrawal statement and withdrawn articles similarly remain in the article history as part of the scientific record.

Authors who wish to initiate a withdrawal on bioRxiv/medRxiv should log-in to the submission system and navigate to the "Submit a Revision" section of their Author Area. After selecting the relevant submission ID#, click on the "Submit a Withdrawal Statement" link to start the withdrawal process. Once an author has submitted a withdrawal statement, bioRxiv/medRxiv will assess the reason for withdrawal, and if it complies with our policies, complete the withdrawal. The signal is then perpetuated to downstream services via normal indexing/crawling processes.

*In very rare cases, a preprint is removed when there is a legal issue such as copyright violation or when information in the article endangers the public or an individual.